Tuesday, April 22, 2008

ULIPs vs MFs

To invest your money in ULIPs (Unit-Linked Insurance Plans) or MFs (Mutual Funds), and to chose in between them, there are many factors that you have to look upon.

Firstly you must know for how many years you want to put your money, means for short-term, mid-term or long-term, same case as with equity market but here you do not have to track it daily or weekly. Once in a month or two is more than enough.
And secondly whether you want to have life-insurance coverage with your plan or not.

Major factor here is time-period, as ULIPs are beneficial only if you want to invest for more than 5-10 years. In case of ULIPs initial years charges are too high. So if you have time horizon for more than 10 years and also want some life-insurance benefit then you can go for ULIP plan. And if you basically want to invest money for some less time period then you should go for MFs. Again in MFs there are several plans available to you like complete equity, and some with combination of debt and equity, so you can invest and take plan as per your risk appetite.

Also if you do not want any life coverage then MF is always a better option. And you can go for separate life-insurance policy which is pure life-insurance policy (term-insurance plan) with no money-back. If you want to go for pure life-insurance, then you can take policy for any amount, and it depends on person to person how much that person wants to give to his/her dependents in case of any mishappen.

Insurance companies themselves admit that if your investment horizon is anything less than 7 years, don't even consider a ULIP. This is because, the charge structure in a ULIP is vastly different from a mutual fund. In the first year, a large chunk of the charges are recovered from investors. It could be as high as 40 per cent, in terms of some annual charges, fund management charges and some other charges as well.

ULIP tend to be expensive propositions (in comparison with mutual funds) during the initial years. However, over longer time horizons, the expenses balance out and ULIPs work out to be cheaper as compared to mutual funds. However, even if the lower expenses of a ULIP vis-à-vis that of a mutual fund scheme were to be considered, the latter would still surface as the better option.

You can make adjustments to your mutual fund portfolio. If you believe you have made a wrong investment decision, you can redeem your investment in a particular mutual fund and invest in another one. Such adjustments are not entirely feasible in a ULIP. If you want to switch in a better ULIP plan of another company, then again you have to start afresh, means again you have to pay those heavy initial charges.

Switch over between ULIPs of different insurance companies is not possible in case their performances are below par. Worse, most ULIPs do not even disclose details about their fund management and their portfolio to the investors.

A simple mutual fund or even a few blue-chip stocks would get you much higher returns and keep your portfolio simple to understand.

So if you want to get the benefits of long term investment and risk cover in one single product, ULIP is the product for you. So it is not an issue, of whether a mutual fund is better or a ULIP. It is about your need. Both can co-exist in your basket of needs. So identify your needs with a financial planner and then pick the product suitable for you. In a ULIP, your premium is divided into your risk cover and your investment. That means, out of the total premium that you pay, a certain percentage will be deducted as risk cover to provide for your insurance and the balance will be invested in a fund. Your risk cover charge will increase every year with your age. As a result the investment allocation will reduce.

Check out various other low risk investment options to invest your money.

1 comment:

Bhagwat said...

Hi anuj, Nice comparison between ULIP and MF, If you do some market study, You see some of the ULIP are having less charges for initial years, as equal to MF like Met life- Met smart plus, charges are 6% for all the years. Some of charge heavy like you said 40%. In my opinion one should not mix up Insurance and Investment as both are different segment, Invest in some good stocks or MF and take a Term plan, you get good returns over period and insurance coverage also. I have posted three chapters on Insurance and investment take a time to visit and comment.